After a Vespa accident two decades ago, the writer spent months in a coma and returned home with severe muscle loss and limited mobility. At age 40, he could not lift himself out of a bathtub and relied on his wife to help. The humiliation of this moment pushed him to seek a way back, leading to a slow recovery through Ashtanga yoga and eventually skate skiing.
A shift in how care is delivered
For years, the standard advice after a concussion was strict rest in a dark room. Newer research challenges this, pointing to aerobic exercise as a more effective path to recovery. A 2019 randomized trial led by John Leddy at the University at Buffalo divided 103 adolescents with sport-related concussions into two groups. One group received aerobic exercise and recovered in a median of 13 days, compared with 17 for those who only stretched. A smaller 2024 trial found that people living with moderate to severe brain injuries for six months or more walked farther and faster after a block of high-intensity training than after conventional rehabilitation.
Read Also: US loses measles elimination status
Medical history has shown that certain approaches to patient care can be misguided. For instance, in the 1950s, patients who had suffered heart attacks were often confined to their beds for extended periods, as it was believed that physical activity posed a risk to their health. Cardiologists Samuel Levine and Bernard Lown challenged this conventional wisdom, and their research, published in JAMA in 1952, helped shift the paradigm. Today, supervised exercise is a standard, reimbursed part of rehabilitation for heart attack patients, and a similar shift has occurred in surgical care, with patients now often encouraged to walk shortly after operations.
The field of brain injury has been slower to adopt a similar approach. Many medical professionals are hesitant to recommend exercise to patients with brain injuries, citing concerns about the potential risks. Patients themselves may also be reluctant to engage in physical activity, as they may believe that rest is the best way to recover. However, while rest is certainly important, it is not the only factor in the recovery process. In fact, research has shown that movement and rest are interconnected, and that exercise can play a key role in the rehabilitation process.
Exercise has been shown to have several benefits for patients with brain injuries. For example, it can help to improve sleep quality, which is often disrupted after a brain injury. Exercise has also been shown to alleviate symptoms of depression, which is a common complication of traumatic brain injury. Additionally, research suggests that exercise may help to promote the production of brain-derived neurotrophic factor, or BDNF, which is often referred to as “fertilizer for the brain.” This could have a positive impact on the recovery process, as BDNF plays a critical role in the growth and development of brain cells.
Read Also: Kennedy backs faith based recovery programs
Despite the potential benefits of exercise, it is often not prioritized in brain injury care. In fact, many patients are not formally prescribed exercise as part of their rehabilitation plan. This can be problematic, as patients may be left to work through the recovery process on their own, without adequate guidance or support. The evidence for exercise in brain injury rehabilitation is not yet full, and more research is needed to fully understand its effects. However, it is clear that individualized care is essential, and that patients should be encouraged to engage in physical activity in a safe manner.
The need for formal prescription
Clinicians working in brain injury care often note a gap between advice and action. Doctors may tell patients to stay active, yet this instruction lacks the specificity required for a complex injury. Without a set plan, patients struggle to gauge safe exertion levels. The writer notes that exercise is rarely encouraged in standard brain-injury care. Formal prescriptions provide the necessary structure for a safe return to activity.
Read Also: U.S. loses measles elimination status after outbreaks
The writer emphasizes that safety and challenge must exist together. Nearly everyone caring for patients after a concussion tries to keep them safe, which often limits progress. A wilderness guide once told the writer he was not pushing hard enough after a ski lesson. The writer realized that he needed both safety and challenge. Medical care must provide the structure for challenge without removing the guardrails of safety.
The need for a formal exercise prescription
Patients with brain injuries often leave medical appointments with medications and advice to stay active, but without a formal plan. An exercise prescription would include a written plan with an intensity set for the patient. This approach provides the necessary support for recovery.
